Ever since I tried my first Juicy Lucy, I've been smitten. Huh? What's that you say? A Juicy Lucy is two burgers melded together, and cheese is in between - essentially a "stuffed" burger, or inverted cheesburger! They're wonderful when done right, and awful when done wrong. I've had both, so when I heard that Jay's Stuffed Burgers were coming to Plymouth's downtown, in the former Zapata's storefront, I was quite excited and intrigued. My wife Lynda and I had just finished mountain biking, and Lynda mentioned that Jay's had just opened a few days now. We were quite hungry after biking, so we headed over to Jay's for a look.
Upon entering, I noticed the giant yellow menus that blazed from the overhead LCD screens. The Jay's staff was very friendly, and greeted us. While perusing the menu offerings, the burger chef gave me a sample of their chili (with turkey). I was told his mother makes the chili, and it definitely had that wonderful homemade flavor that is a rarity in many restaurants. Jay's definitely has some chili that makes it tough to choose between chili and a burger! But, Lynda and I were there for burgers, so burgers it must be. Lynda is a vegetarian, so she's often not able to join in on the burgery fun whenever we go out, so she was elated to be able to choose a veggie burger off the menu. It's not stuffed, but that's OK. I chose the Paul Bunyan stuffed burger - stuffed with mashed potatoes and sharp cheddar, and we'd share an order of sweet potato fries.
Made to order, we waited about 5-10 minutes, which is perfectly acceptable, but I can imagine this will cause the fast food crowd to wince a bit while waiting for their food. This is hand made food, not pre-cooked fast food, so waiting is par for the course. Upon retrieving our order, we set upon it hungrily. Lynda was greeted by a sizeably large veggie burger, beautifully toasted bun, cheese, grilled onions, and all the nice fixings. The remarkable thing about it, was that it achieved that nice gooey bun/burger melding that is the hallmark of all truly delicious burgers. Vegetarians, you have another place to try! As for my Paul Bunyan, it too had that incredible melding of flavors, burger + bun, interplay. I'd recommend eating the burger partially wrapped in its covering for there's lots going on here, especially when dipped in the aus jus sauce supplied with the Paul Bunyan. It's a wonderful burger, just enough cheese to not overpower the beef flavor, and the crispy yet buttery bun ties it all together. It's just plain great. I couldn't help but think that the only thing that would make it better would be a cold beer. We'll be back!
So, if yer hankerin' for a stuffed burger and don't know where to go, try Jay's Stuffed Burgers, 600 West Ann Arbor Trail, Plymouth, Michigan. https://www.facebook.com/GetStuffedAtJays/info
Upon entering, I noticed the giant yellow menus that blazed from the overhead LCD screens. The Jay's staff was very friendly, and greeted us. While perusing the menu offerings, the burger chef gave me a sample of their chili (with turkey). I was told his mother makes the chili, and it definitely had that wonderful homemade flavor that is a rarity in many restaurants. Jay's definitely has some chili that makes it tough to choose between chili and a burger! But, Lynda and I were there for burgers, so burgers it must be. Lynda is a vegetarian, so she's often not able to join in on the burgery fun whenever we go out, so she was elated to be able to choose a veggie burger off the menu. It's not stuffed, but that's OK. I chose the Paul Bunyan stuffed burger - stuffed with mashed potatoes and sharp cheddar, and we'd share an order of sweet potato fries.
Made to order, we waited about 5-10 minutes, which is perfectly acceptable, but I can imagine this will cause the fast food crowd to wince a bit while waiting for their food. This is hand made food, not pre-cooked fast food, so waiting is par for the course. Upon retrieving our order, we set upon it hungrily. Lynda was greeted by a sizeably large veggie burger, beautifully toasted bun, cheese, grilled onions, and all the nice fixings. The remarkable thing about it, was that it achieved that nice gooey bun/burger melding that is the hallmark of all truly delicious burgers. Vegetarians, you have another place to try! As for my Paul Bunyan, it too had that incredible melding of flavors, burger + bun, interplay. I'd recommend eating the burger partially wrapped in its covering for there's lots going on here, especially when dipped in the aus jus sauce supplied with the Paul Bunyan. It's a wonderful burger, just enough cheese to not overpower the beef flavor, and the crispy yet buttery bun ties it all together. It's just plain great. I couldn't help but think that the only thing that would make it better would be a cold beer. We'll be back!
So, if yer hankerin' for a stuffed burger and don't know where to go, try Jay's Stuffed Burgers, 600 West Ann Arbor Trail, Plymouth, Michigan. https://www.facebook.com/GetStuffedAtJays/info